I did not love this eyeliner. I found that it smudge all under my eye within an hour or so of application. This could work as a smokey eye pencil but you would have to put eyeshadow on top of it in order to keep it from smudging on its own. It also did not last for a very long time on my waterline. I received this in a blockbuster package so I am unsure of the actual cost of it or where you can purchase it. If I had the choice, I would definitely not purchase it again.